Choose To Believe
John 12:39-40
“Therefore they could not believe, because that Esaias said again, He hath blinded their eyes, and hardened their heart; that they should not see with their eyes, nor understand with their heart, and be converted, and I should heal them.”
In this moment, the words of the prophet Isaiah, as echoed by John, expose a profound spiritual truth—belief is a choice. You might read this verse and feel a certain gravity, a sense of mystery that leaves you wondering: How could people not believe? How could they be blinded and hardened to the truth?
Let me tell you, the truth isn’t just an external fact waiting to be discovered; it’s a force that engages your heart and mind. But for some, the heart resists, and the eyes refuse to see. This passage shows the results of a heart that has chosen to reject God’s truth—rejection that, over time, leads to a self-imposed blindness. And yet, that blindness isn’t a passive state; it’s the result of a conscious refusal to believe.
The Nature of the Blindness
In John 12:39-40, we are confronted with a striking paradox: they could not believe because of a deliberate hardening, a spiritual blindness. This doesn’t mean they were incapable of belief in a mechanical sense, as though they were spiritually powerless; rather, it speaks to a willful rejection. Their hearts and eyes were closed to the divine revelation standing right before them. John, quoting Isaiah, shows that God allows people to persist in their rejection, in effect reinforcing their choice.
I have heard many ask, “Why would God cause them to be blind? Isn’t He good and merciful?” Let’s address that. First, it’s crucial to recognize that God does not arbitrarily harden hearts; He responds to the persistent decisions people make to reject the truth. The hardening is not imposed in a vacuum, but is the consequence of their free-willed rejection. God honors the choices they make. When a person continually resists the prompting of the Holy Spirit, they create a thick veil between themselves and God’s truth. Over time, that veil becomes impenetrable.
Understanding Hardening and Blindness in Scripture
Throughout the Bible, we see the theme of God hardening hearts in response to human choices. In Exodus, Pharaoh’s heart was hardened, but this didn’t happen in isolation. At first, Pharaoh’s own decisions hardened his heart, and then God confirmed that hardening by allowing him to persist in his rebellion (Exodus 9:12, 10:1). This same principle is applied here in John. If you reject the truth long enough, you will no longer see the truth clearly. Your heart becomes like stone, unable to feel the compassion, the longing, and the healing that God offers.
Consider the sobering warning in Romans 1:21-24. Paul explains how humanity, although aware of God’s power and divinity through creation, chose to reject that knowledge. As a result, God gave them over to their sinful desires. This hardening was a judgment, a consequence of their unwillingness to acknowledge the truth.
The Free Will to Choose
But you must understand, this blindness isn’t about a lack of ability—it’s about a choice. It’s not that God is withholding the ability to believe; He is allowing people to choose whether or not to accept the light He has given them. The danger comes when people resist God’s call for so long that they reach a point of no return. That is the spiritual peril we must all avoid.
Scripture affirms the power of choice repeatedly. Jesus Himself said in Matthew 7:7 that if you seek, you will find. He did not say, “if you are predestined to seek, you will find,” but if you choose to seek, you will find. This is a direct challenge to us all: Will you choose to believe?
Consider the invitation that Jesus extends in Revelation 3:20:
“Behold, I stand at the door and knock; if anyone hears My voice and opens the door, I will come in to him and dine with him, and he with Me.”
This is an image of free will at its finest. Jesus knocks at the door of your heart. He doesn’t force the door open, nor does He blindfold you so that you cannot see Him. He simply knocks, and you have the choice: will you open the door? Or will you harden your heart, as the people in John 12 did?
The Compassionate Call of God
Don’t misinterpret this message as one of condemnation but as one of hope and invitation. God does not delight in the hardening of hearts. In fact, He sent His Son into the world not to condemn the world but to save it (John 3:17). He seeks that all people would come to the knowledge of the truth, and He gives each of us the opportunity to believe.
Yet, here’s the crux: the choice is yours. Will you open your eyes? Will you soften your heart to Him? Will you allow Him to heal you?
The invitation to be healed is still open. If you find yourself in a place where your heart feels distant or your vision clouded, understand that it is not too late. God’s mercy is greater than your stubbornness, and His grace is deeper than your blindness. There’s always an opportunity to choose to believe.
Scriptural Insights on the Freedom to Choose
Let me offer a few more scriptural insights that underscore the importance of this choice:
- Luke 19:41-42 – Jesus weeps over Jerusalem, saying, “If you had known, even you, especially in this your day, the things that make for your peace! But now they are hidden from your eyes.” The people of Jerusalem had the opportunity to choose peace, but they rejected it.
- John 5:39-40 – Jesus tells the religious leaders, “You search the Scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that bear witness about Me, yet you refuse to come to Me that you may have life.” Their study of Scripture was not enough if it did not lead them to the choice to believe in Jesus Himself.
- 2 Corinthians 4:4 – “In their case the god of this world has blinded the minds of the unbelievers, to keep them from seeing the light of the gospel of the glory of Christ.” This echoes the idea of spiritual blindness but also emphasizes the active work of the enemy. Yet, this blindness is still a result of choices—their willingness to be deceived.
- Hebrews 3:15 – “Today, if you hear His voice, do not harden your hearts as in the rebellion.” Again, this is a call to action. If you hear the truth, do not harden your heart. Today is the day to choose to believe.
Conclusion: The Power of Your Choice
You have the power to choose to believe. You can soften your heart today. This choice is not just a one-time event, but a daily commitment to remain open to God’s truth, to welcome His healing, and to let His light illuminate your life.
If you find yourself in a place where your heart feels hard or your vision is dim, don’t despair. Acknowledge that you have the power to choose—to believe. Pray for God to open your eyes and soften your heart, and trust in His willingness to heal and restore you. Your belief is not something forced upon you; it is an invitation to engage, to see, and to be transformed.
So I ask you, will you choose to believe today?
The Ultimate Teaching on Predestination: A Choice of Salvation
This idea, that the passage in John 12:39-40 could be interpreted as the ultimate teaching on predestination, is one that calls for careful reflection. It could suggest that these people—those who could not believe—were never given the opportunity to accept the truth because, as Isaiah prophesied, God had blotted out their vision and hardened their hearts. But as we dive deeper into Scripture, we see that this interpretation does not align with the full counsel of God’s Word.
Let’s examine this truth from a deeper perspective, for it is a matter that hinges on your understanding of God’s character, His justice, and His mercy. Is God, in His sovereignty, choosing who will believe and who will not? Or is there something more going on here—something that reveals the delicate balance between God’s sovereignty and human responsibility? The answer is clear from Scripture: God’s call to salvation is universal, and everyone is given the opportunity to choose.
The Invitation to All: A Universal Call to Salvation
Let’s look at some of the clearest passages that affirm the universal nature of God’s invitation to salvation. These verses stand in stark contrast to any interpretation of predestination that would suggest some people are inherently denied the chance to believe.
In Romans 10:13, Paul declares:
“For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved.”
This is not a restrictive statement; it is an all-encompassing, inclusive promise. It’s a declaration that salvation is available to anyone who chooses to call on the name of the Lord. There are no exceptions here. There is no one excluded from the opportunity to respond to God’s call. You must understand, this is not a statement of exclusion—it is an invitation of grace, wide open and unrestricted. God is not saying, “Only some can come to me,” He is saying, “All may come.”
The Open Door of Salvation
We see this invitation repeated in Revelation 3:20, where Jesus says,
“Behold, I stand at the door, and knock: if any man hear my voice, and open the door, I will come in to him, and will sup with him, and he with me.”
This is the invitation of a Savior seeking relationship, seeking fellowship with humanity. Jesus doesn’t say, “I knock only on the doors of the elect,” or “I knock only on the doors of those who will inevitably choose Me.” No. He knocks on the door of every heart. He waits patiently for you to open that door. If you hear His voice, the choice is yours—to respond, to open, to invite Him in.
Now consider the striking words in Revelation 22:17,
“And the Spirit and the bride say, Come. And let him that heareth say, Come. And let him that is athirst come. And whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely.”
This is an invitation to all. It is a call to anyone who thirsts, anyone who desires, anyone who is willing. There is no exclusion in this call. Notice that it is not restricted by race, status, or predestination. It simply says, whosoever will. If you will choose to believe, you can take of the water of life—freely, abundantly. God does not bar the door to salvation. He opens it wide, calling all to come.
Universal Opportunity, Not Denied Access
I understand that John 12:39-40 might make it seem as if there are those who are given no opportunity to believe, but when you place this passage in the context of the entire Word of God, a different picture emerges. The Bible is clear that no one is excluded from the opportunity to be saved. Titus 2:11 says,
“For the grace of God that bringeth salvation hath appeared to all men.”
Do you hear that? All men. This means that God has made His grace available to everyone, and that means everyone has the opportunity to respond. There is no one who has been denied the opportunity to accept salvation. God does not offer grace to some and deny it to others. His grace is not limited or selective. The choice to believe, to open your heart, to receive that grace—it is yours. It is always yours.
Understanding the Paradox of Hardening and Invitation
Now, you may wonder, how do we reconcile this with the hardening of hearts in John 12:39-40 and the prophecies of Isaiah? It’s important to understand that the hardening mentioned in this passage isn’t about God actively withholding the chance to believe. Rather, it reflects a judgment on those who have continually rejected the truth. The hardening of hearts in Scripture, especially in passages like this one, is not a moment of God pre-determining who will believe or who will not. It’s the natural consequence of repeatedly rejecting God’s call.
When people persist in rejecting God’s offer of salvation, they harden their own hearts. And God, in His justice, allows them to do so. This is a tragic, sobering reality. But it doesn’t change the fact that the door of salvation is still open, that the invitation is still extended, that the opportunity to respond is always there.
A Call to Understand God’s Sovereignty and Human Responsibility
So where does that leave us? We must recognize that in His sovereignty, God has given us the gift of choice. Yes, God is all-powerful, and yes, He knows the end from the beginning, but He has still chosen to give humanity the freedom to choose—to choose to believe or to reject. This is not a contradiction of His sovereignty, but rather an expression of His deep desire for relationship. God does not force us into His kingdom. He calls, He invites, and He allows us to choose.
In the end, God’s predestination is not about a predetermined list of those who will believe, but about His sovereign plan for salvation—His plan for whosoever will. God’s plan is one of grace, of invitation, of freedom to choose.
Conclusion: The Call Is for You
If you have ever doubted the availability of salvation for you, know this: God’s invitation is for you. There is no predestined exclusion. There is no “group” chosen in some far-off, distant way that leaves others out. The invitation is open to everyone.
Jesus is knocking at your door right now. The grace of God is available to you. The choice to believe, to respond to that grace, is yours. And you can respond, even today, to the call that says, “Come, and take the water of life freely.”
Will you open the door? Will you answer His call? It’s a choice that belongs to you—and it’s the most important choice you will ever make.
The Power of Choice and the Limits of God’s Intervention
In Mark 6:5, we find a fascinating and often overlooked truth about the nature of God’s interaction with humanity. The verse states,
“And he could there do no mighty work, save that he laid his hands upon a few sick folk, and healed them.”
At first glance, this might appear to be a limitation on Jesus’ power, as if there were something He couldn’t do. But as we delve deeper into the context, it becomes clear that Jesus’ inability to perform mighty works was not due to a lack of power—it was due to a choice He made. Jesus, in His wisdom and respect for human freedom, chose not to force His miraculous power upon those who rejected Him. He could have done mighty works, but He refrained because of the people’s lack of faith and their rejection of Him.
This brings us to a profound truth: God’s power is not wielded arbitrarily or against the will of humanity. The miraculous, the supernatural, the mighty works of God—these are not force-fed to the unwilling. God’s omnipotence is never in question, but He consistently honors the freedom He has given us to choose whether or not to receive His work in our lives.
The Choice of Rejection: A Barrier to Belief
Just as Jesus chose to withhold His mighty works from those who lacked faith, the same principle applies in the context of belief. The Jews in John 12:39-40 could not believe—not because they were unable, but because they chose not to believe. In this case, they stumbled at the stumblingstone, as Paul writes in Romans 9:32,
“They stumbled at that stumblingstone.”
The stumblingstone was Jesus Himself. He was the very foundation of salvation, yet they tripped over Him, rejecting the very One who came to save them. They chose not to believe. They allowed their preconceived notions, their pride, their self-sufficiency, and their rejection of God’s plan to blind them to the truth. This choice—this rejection—is what led to their inability to believe.
Isaiah’s Prophecy: Foreseeing a Rejected Savior
Some might argue, “But didn’t Isaiah prophesy that many would not believe? Doesn’t that suggest predestination?” It’s essential to understand that Isaiah’s prophecy in Isaiah 53:1 is not a statement of divine exclusion, but of divine foreknowledge. Isaiah foresaw that the Messiah would be rejected by many, not because God preordained their rejection, but because He knew the choices of people. Isaiah predicted that most would reject the message of salvation, but this was not a predetermined fate—it was a consequence of their choice to refuse God’s offer.
Isaiah says,
“Who hath believed our report? And to whom is the arm of the Lord revealed?”
This isn’t a declaration that people were predestined to reject the Messiah, but a recognition of the reality that many would, because of their hardened hearts and their refusal to accept the truth. Isaiah saw that the message of the Messiah would be disregarded by the masses, and this is exactly what happened. Yet, the invitation to salvation remained open to all who would believe.
The Danger of Rejecting God’s Call
The tragedy of rejecting Jesus is that it cuts people off from the very source of life, wisdom, and knowledge. Colossians 2:3 reveals that in Christ, “are hid all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge.” To reject Jesus, to stumble at the stumblingstone, is to refuse the very essence of life and understanding. Those who reject Him are choosing to walk away from the greatest treasure in the universe—the offer of eternal life, peace with God, and wisdom that surpasses human understanding.
This isn’t a decision that can be made lightly. Jesus, in His mercy, calls all to come to Him, to receive His life and wisdom. But He will not force Himself upon anyone. God is not in the business of coercion—He allows us to choose. He offers, but He does not impose. You are free to choose to believe, or free to choose to reject.
The Role of Isaiah’s Prophecy in the Divine Narrative
Isaiah did not prophecy that God would predetermine the rejection of the Messiah. Rather, he prophesied that the rejection would be a natural outcome of human choice. The people would reject Him, not because God had chosen them to be lost, but because their hearts were unwilling to receive the truth. God, in His infinite wisdom, knew this would happen, but that foreknowledge doesn’t equate to predestination. It is a recognition of human free will and the tragic consequence of rejecting the invitation to salvation.
Isaiah 53:1 is not a fatalistic statement; it is a prophetic warning. Isaiah foresaw that many would reject the report of salvation because they would choose not to believe. But it is vital to understand that this rejection is not God’s doing. God’s call to salvation is extended to all, and no one is denied the opportunity to receive the Savior. The choice is always, and forever, ours to make.
The Importance of Choosing Wisely
Be careful what you choose.
This is the underlying message of these truths. Jesus, in His love, will not force Himself upon you. You have the power to accept or reject His offer of life. The Jews in Jesus’ day rejected Him, not because they could not believe, but because they chose not to. And just as Jesus refrained from performing mighty works in Nazareth due to their lack of faith, so too does God honor your choice to either accept or reject Him.
Every day, you are presented with a choice: will you believe, or will you stumble? Will you receive the treasures of wisdom and knowledge found in Christ, or will you walk away, blind to the riches that await you? The decision is yours, and it is a decision that shapes not only this life, but eternity.
Conclusion: The Gift and Responsibility of Choice
God’s sovereignty is never in question. His power is not diminished by our choices. But His love compels Him to give us the freedom to choose. The call to salvation is universal, and the invitation is open to all. Jesus knocks at the door of every heart, but He will not force His way in. The freedom to reject or receive Him is your choice.
So, I urge you: Choose wisely. The stakes are eternal. The treasure is priceless. Open your heart to the Savior, and you will find the fullness of life. Reject Him, and you will stumble, unable to see the truth that stands before you. Choose to believe, and you will find the mighty works of God unfolding in your life. The choice is yours. And it is the most important choice you will ever make.